Introduction: The Slow-Motion Collapse
You feel it every time you walk into a supermarket. There’s a palpable friction. You see the half-hearted attempts to compete with the modern world: the clumsy integration of online order-picking that clogs up the aisles, the sad-looking café near the entrance, the ever-expanding "organic" section that somehow still feels overly processed. These are the frantic, last-ditch efforts of a business model gasping for air.
For years, we’ve been told the threats are online delivery services like Instacart, meal-kit companies like Blue Apron, and the consumer’s pivot toward farmers' markets. And yes, those are legitimate competitors. They’ve successfully attacked the supermarket on the fronts of convenience and quality. But they are merely symptoms of a much deeper rot. They are tremors before the earthquake.
The core problem isn't the competition; it's the model itself. The traditional grocery store is a high-overhead, low-margin warehouse built for a world that is rapidly vanishing. It’s a solution optimized to stock and sell tens of thousands of shelf-stable, processed, packaged goods. Its entire layout, its supply chain, its very economic foundation, is based on the assumption that you, the customer, want endless choice within a specific paradigm of food.
But what if that paradigm shatters?
I’m here to tell you that the real disruption—the one that will make today’s supermarkets as relevant as a blacksmith shop in the age of the automobile—is not a new technology or a clever business model. It's a fundamental shift in what people eat. A growing and influential segment of the population is adopting what can be called a "Proper Human Diet" (PHD)—a way of eating that is extremely low in carbohydrates and completely free of sugar and processed foods.
This isn't just another fad. It's a dietary framework that acts as a set of strict, non-negotiable constraints. And when you apply those constraints, you realize that this movement won’t just disrupt the grocery store; it will make it functionally obsolete by fundamentally changing the Job-to-be-Done of acquiring food.
Redefining the Job: From "Buying Groceries" to "Sourcing Compliant Fuel"
To understand the scale of this threat, you first need to stop thinking about "grocery shopping" and start thinking about the Job-to-be-Done (JTBD). The JTBD framework teaches us that people don't buy products and services; they "hire" them to get a job done in their lives. You don't want a drill; you want a quarter-inch hole in your wall. The drill is just the solution you hire for that job.
For decades, the primary job for which people hired a supermarket was to "acquire ingredients for meals at home." The store's value proposition was variety, one-stop convenience, and low prices. It was a place for discovery, for Browse, for impulse buys. You went in with a list but came out with much more. The store was designed to facilitate this meandering, often inefficient, treasure hunt.
The follower of a Proper Human Diet has an entirely different job.
Because their diet is defined by exclusion—no sugars, no grains, no seed oils, no processed anything—their job is no longer a treasure hunt. It is a precise, needs-driven procurement task. Their Job-to-be-Done is to source specific, non-processed animal products and a very limited selection of produce.
Think about the implications of that. When you walk into a 40,000-square-foot supermarket with that job in mind, what do you see? You see a landscape of irrelevance.
The entire center of the store—the endless aisles of cereal, soda, snacks, cookies, bread, pasta, canned soups, frozen pizzas, and ready-meals—is a "no-fly zone." It's 100% waste to you.
The deli counter is a minefield of sugar-cured meats and mayonnaise-drenched salads.
Even the produce section is mostly off-limits, filled with high-sugar fruits and starchy vegetables.
Suddenly, the supermarket's greatest asset—its vast choice—becomes its greatest liability. It's a bloated, inefficient, and frustrating experience. You are forced to navigate a massive warehouse designed for a completely different consumer to find the 5% of items that meet your strict criteria. The solution is no longer a fit for the job. You are hiring a sledgehammer to hang a picture frame.
This creates an enormous opportunity for a new solution that is perfectly tailored to this new, highly specific job. This customer doesn't need choice. They need quality, consistency, and purity. They need a service, not a supermarket.
The Coming "Post-Farm" Economy: A New Production Paradigm
This is where we must elevate the level of abstraction. If the job has changed so fundamentally, then the entire system for fulfilling that job is up for reinvention. The current system—a convoluted and fragile chain of farms, processing plants, logistics networks, and retail outlets—is a legacy solution built around the old job. It’s ripe for complete replacement.
The Inefficient Present: A Fragile Chain of Dependencies
Think about what it takes to get a simple steak to your plate today. A cow is raised on a ranch, often for years. It's then transported to a feedlot, then to a slaughterhouse, then to a processing plant where it's butchered and packaged. From there, it's shipped via refrigerated truck to a massive distribution center, then shipped again to a grocery store, where it sits under fluorescent lights, losing freshness and value every second until you buy it.
This chain is incredibly complex, energy-intensive, and wasteful. It's susceptible to shocks like weather, disease, and fuel costs. The quality of the end product is highly variable. It's a system designed for mass production, not for precision or quality. It’s an analog solution in a digital age.
What's Working Today: Bypassing the Middleman
We're already seeing the first generation of solutions that get parts of this job done better by abstracting away some of the complexity. Direct-to-consumer services like ButcherBox or Crowd Cow are a great example. They bypass the grocery store entirely, creating a direct link between a network of producers and the end consumer.
They get the job done better by offering higher quality and more transparency. They get it done more conveniently by delivering directly to your door. They are a significant improvement, but they are still working within the old production paradigm. They are a better interface for the same flawed, centralized system. They are a faster horse, not a car.
The Novel Future: Decentralized, On-Demand Production
The real revolution comes when we change the production method itself. This isn't a far-future fantasy; the enabling technologies are maturing as we speak. This is the "post-farm" economy.
Novel Concept 1: Cellular Agriculture. Imagine this: instead of raising a 1,500-pound animal for a few hundred pounds of steak, you cultivate the steak directly from animal cells in a clean, controlled environment. This is cellular agriculture. It is not "fake meat" or a plant-based substitute; it is real animal protein and fat, grown without the animal. Think of it like a craft brewery. Instead of brewing beer, a local facility brews beef, pork, or lamb. The "inputs" are simple nutrients, and the "output" is a pure, perfectly marbled, and pathogen-free cut of meat. This completely decouples meat production from land use, water consumption, and the traditional agricultural cycle. Production moves from vast, rural landscapes to compact, efficient hubs in or near the cities where people live.
Novel Concept 2: Automated, Local Vertical Farms. For the limited range of produce that fits within a PHD (like leafy greens, broccoli, or avocados), we no longer need to rely on seasonal crops grown thousands of miles away. Automated vertical farms can operate 24/7, 365 days a year, in any climate. They use a fraction of the water and zero pesticides. Just like with cellular agriculture, this moves production from the country to the city, ensuring unparalleled freshness and eliminating the costs and waste of long-haul transportation.
These two technologies, working in concert, don't just improve the old system. They obliterate it. They create a new foundation for our entire food infrastructure.
The Future of Distribution: From Supermarket to Super-Hub
When you combine on-demand, local production with the highly specific needs of the PHD consumer, the supermarket isn't just unnecessary; it's absurd. The logical endpoint of this evolution is the "Super-Hub."
This isn't a store. It's a local, highly automated facility that integrates production and distribution under one roof. Think of a neighborhood-level utility. One part of the building houses the cellular agriculture cultivators. Another houses the vertical farm modules.
This new solution gets the job done at a completely different level:
It gets it done better: The quality is unparalleled. The meat is "harvested" the day you receive it. The produce is picked hours before. It's perfectly consistent, free from contaminants, and tailored to exact specifications.
It gets it done at a lower cost: The model eliminates the largest costs in the current system: transportation, spoilage (which can be as high as 30-40%), and the massive overhead of retail real estate and labor.
It has fewer visible features: There are no aisles. No brands. No checkout lines. No confusing labels. The complexity is hidden, or abstracted away. The interface is a simple subscription app on your phone. You select the items you need for the week, and they are produced for you.
In this world, the "job performer" is no longer the "shopper." You no longer need to physically navigate a space, inspect products, and transport them home. The new job performer is a "subscriber" or a "manager" of their household's nutritional needs. The job is elevated from a physical chore to a simple act of digital curation. The friction is gone. The job is finally done perfectly.
Imagining the New System (with Creativity Triggers)
It can be hard to visualize a system so different from our current reality. To help, we can use a set of "Creativity Triggers"—prompts that force us to think about a problem along different dimensions. They help us systematically dismantle the old solution and construct a new one.
Here’s how applying these triggers to the job of "sourcing compliant food" leads us directly to the Super-Hub model:
Conclusion: The Innovator's Opportunity
The inevitable decline of the supermarket is not a tragedy. It is the single greatest business opportunity in the food and agriculture sector in the last hundred years.
For too long, innovation in this space has been incremental—a better app, a new type of checkout, a more efficient warehouse robot. These are optimizations of a dying model. They are akin to inventing a more comfortable saddle for a horse when the automobile is just around the corner.
The real opportunity isn't to build a better grocery store. It's to build its replacement. It’s about building the infrastructure for an entirely new food system: one that is decentralized, on-demand, resilient, and radically more efficient. It’s a system that finally aligns the solution with the real Job-to-be-Done: getting the highest quality fuel for our bodies with the least amount of friction possible.
The innovators, entrepreneurs, and investors who see this shift coming won't be fighting for thinning margins in the retail aisle. They will be building the utilities of the future.
What do you think is the biggest hurdle to overcome in moving to this post-farm, post-supermarket world? Is it the technology, regulation, or consumer behavior? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Follow me on 𝕏: https://x.com/mikeboysen
If you'd like to see how I apply a higher level of abstraction to the front-end of innovation, please reach out. My availability is limited.
Mike Boysen - www.pjtbd.com
Why fail fast when you can succeed the first time?
📆 Book an appointment: https://pjtbd.com/book-mike
Join our community: https://pjtbd.com/join
Share this post